NWA Achieves Complete Summary Judgment Affirmance from the First Circuit

On November 19, 2026, NWA obtained a full affirmance from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit of the summary judgment obtained on behalf of JPMorgan Chase. Plaintiffs asserted nine claims, including breach of fiduciary duty, breach of contract, and breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing, against JPMC and JPMC’s program manager Chickasaw Capital Management after Peter Doelger—against JPMC’s written recommendation—moved $33 million of pre-existing Master Limited Partnership (MLP) investments into JPMC’s MLP program. These holdings declined sharply during the COVID-19 downturn.
The First Circuit disposed eight of the claims that required causation, holding that Plaintiffs waived causation by dismissing Defendants’ causation argument as “ridiculous” rather than responding with evidence that Peter would have handled his MLP investment differently but for Defendants’ conduct. The Court also rejected Plaintiffs’ remaining challenges, including their attempt to void the letter acknowledging that Peter’s investment went against JPMC’s recommendation, and their eleventh-hour bid to add J.P. Morgan Securities as a defendant.
The NWA team behind JPMC’s third straight win in the case includes Tibor Nagy, Tracy Appleton, Patrick McGee, Jacob Goldenberg, and David Moosmann. Tracy argued the appeal. Tibor, Tracy, and their team also represented JPMC in its summary judgment wins before the Magistrate Judge and U.S. District Court Judge for the District of Massachusetts.



